The prevailing literature presents the smart city as an instrument of administrative efficiency and civic participation. This article challenges that interpretation by examining whether, and to what extent, the algorithmic monitoring of urban behaviour, by replacing discursive deliberation, may erode urban democracy rather than strengthen it. The issue is particularly relevant for candidate countries seeking accession to the European Union: in the absence of participatory safeguards calibrated to the algorithmic nature of planning, urban digitalisation may produce formal integration at the level of technical standards, while generating substantive regression in participation and the rule of law. Methodologically, the article adopts a qualitative research design combining legal analysis, theoretical reconstruction and documentary analysis. The legal framework relies on Italian legal scholarship on algorithmic legality and on the case law of the Italian Council of State concerning automated decisionmaking, read in conjunction with European Union law, including the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, the General Data Protection Regulation and Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 on artificial intelligence. The theoretical framework draws on international critical literature on the smart city and on Italian constitutional scholarship on "governance by numbers". The empirical component consists of a documentary analysis of four planning instruments adopted in the Tirana-Durrës area between 2016 and 2020. The analysis leads to three main findings. First, sensor-based monitoring of urban behaviour risks confusing constrained symptoms with genuine preferences; planning based on such data replaces deliberation with extraction and produces a representation of urban needs that differs from the one that would emerge through deliberative debate. Secondly, urban data are structurally partial, since they exclude what cannot be sensorised (landscape constraints, the symbolic value of spaces, proximity public goods), and this partiality affects the substantive legality of planning choices, not merely their administrative rationality. Thirdly, the co-production of plans by international technical consultancies – useful and legitimate in terms of expertise – assumes in the cases examined a substitutive, not merely auxiliary, function vis-à-vis local deliberation, reducing the space of procedural participation to a moment of ex post formal legitimation. Legally, these dynamics directly affect three pillars of Italian administrative law that can be applied to the Albanian case: participation in administrative proceedings, the duty to give reasons and the attributability of the decision. The article argues that effective participation should be treated as a substantive requirement of the European integration process and formulates three operational recommendations: including the participatory structure among the criteria for assessing conformity with the acquis communautaire; applying the principles of algorithmic legality to smart systems, namely transparency, nonexclusivity and non-discrimination; and introducing reversibility clauses in concession contracts concerning sensor-based infrastructures.
Smart City and Digital Urban Democracy: A Betrayed Promise? Towards Conscious Smart Urbanism in Albania
Riccardo Merli
2026-01-01
Abstract
The prevailing literature presents the smart city as an instrument of administrative efficiency and civic participation. This article challenges that interpretation by examining whether, and to what extent, the algorithmic monitoring of urban behaviour, by replacing discursive deliberation, may erode urban democracy rather than strengthen it. The issue is particularly relevant for candidate countries seeking accession to the European Union: in the absence of participatory safeguards calibrated to the algorithmic nature of planning, urban digitalisation may produce formal integration at the level of technical standards, while generating substantive regression in participation and the rule of law. Methodologically, the article adopts a qualitative research design combining legal analysis, theoretical reconstruction and documentary analysis. The legal framework relies on Italian legal scholarship on algorithmic legality and on the case law of the Italian Council of State concerning automated decisionmaking, read in conjunction with European Union law, including the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, the General Data Protection Regulation and Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 on artificial intelligence. The theoretical framework draws on international critical literature on the smart city and on Italian constitutional scholarship on "governance by numbers". The empirical component consists of a documentary analysis of four planning instruments adopted in the Tirana-Durrës area between 2016 and 2020. The analysis leads to three main findings. First, sensor-based monitoring of urban behaviour risks confusing constrained symptoms with genuine preferences; planning based on such data replaces deliberation with extraction and produces a representation of urban needs that differs from the one that would emerge through deliberative debate. Secondly, urban data are structurally partial, since they exclude what cannot be sensorised (landscape constraints, the symbolic value of spaces, proximity public goods), and this partiality affects the substantive legality of planning choices, not merely their administrative rationality. Thirdly, the co-production of plans by international technical consultancies – useful and legitimate in terms of expertise – assumes in the cases examined a substitutive, not merely auxiliary, function vis-à-vis local deliberation, reducing the space of procedural participation to a moment of ex post formal legitimation. Legally, these dynamics directly affect three pillars of Italian administrative law that can be applied to the Albanian case: participation in administrative proceedings, the duty to give reasons and the attributability of the decision. The article argues that effective participation should be treated as a substantive requirement of the European integration process and formulates three operational recommendations: including the participatory structure among the criteria for assessing conformity with the acquis communautaire; applying the principles of algorithmic legality to smart systems, namely transparency, nonexclusivity and non-discrimination; and introducing reversibility clauses in concession contracts concerning sensor-based infrastructures.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


